Ammerländer has been making Butterkäse since 1885. The company survived two world wars, the collapse of empires, and the invention of "low-fat everything."
None of that prepared them for a 36-year-old English teacher in Fayetteville, Georgia.
The recipe is insulting in its simplicity: slow-bake a sweet potato, split it open, shove in a block of Butterkäse. No chef skills required. You eat it like a hot dog.
Courtney Cook started posting lunch videos seven months ago. She now has over a million followers. Individual videos have crossed 7 million views. Celebrity chef Alex Guarnaschelli tried a version on camera—with American cheese, because she couldn't find the original—and gave it "10/10." The hashtag #sweetpotatoandcheese has hundreds of copycat posts.
What you're looking at is a demand shock. And demand shocks keep happening.
The Pattern Nobody's Building For
In February 2021, a Finnish food blogger's three-year-old recipe for baked feta pasta hit TikTok. Within weeks, Kroger's specialty cheese manager called it "the largest and most geographically broad interest and sales increase in a product that I have personally ever seen." Feta sales spiked 200-300% across the country. Stores from Trader Joe's to Publix sold out. The hashtag #fetapasta hit 650 million views.
The pattern keeps repeating. Gopuff reported a 166% year-over-year increase in cottage cheese orders in 2024 after high-protein recipes flooded TikTok. Cherry juice and Poppi searches jumped 111% in January after the Sleepy Girl Mocktail went viral. Trader Joe's kimbap triggered scarcity behavior—people hunting, hoarding, and posting restocks like sneaker drops. The shortage lasted months.
Retailers see this coming. Aldi told Axios they have "a team of trend experts and buyers monitoring social media to spot emerging trends and stock must-have items." Datassential launched a Social Listening tool claiming 98% accuracy on food trend forecasts. Instacart built Shoppable Recipes in 2022 to let creators link ingredient lists directly to checkout.
The infrastructure exists. The early warning exists. What's missing is the execution layer that turns viral attention into reliable carts before shelves empty.
Platforms are nibbling at pieces of this. Instacart has creator integrations with Tasty and Hearst food brands. TikTok lets select partners earn payouts on orders. Datassential sells trend alerts to foodservice operators. But nobody owns the cross-platform workflow: trend detection → local cart → intelligent substitutions → creator attribution → brand monetization. That's the gap.
The Play
The obvious move is DTC kits: "Buy the official Butterkäse sweet potato kit!" It'll work a little. It'll also trap you in perishability, thin margins, regional distribution, and copycats that appear the moment you prove demand.
The smarter play is becoming the translation layer between viral attention and grocery checkout.
Detect a food moment early. Generate the shoppable bundle. Map it to what's actually in stock locally. Offer intelligent swaps when the hero ingredient sells out. Pay the creator. Sell the default slots to brands. You're building the operating system for viral food commerce.
Why this works now:
The rails exist. Instacart's Shoppable Recipes infrastructure lets creators link ingredient lists to carts. TikTok's Jump program enables third-party integrations. The #FoodTikTok hashtag has nearly 60 billion views.
Trend windows are measurable. TikTok now publishes Market Insights showing creators exactly when trends spike and decay. Datassential tracks social-to-menu velocity. The half-life of a viral recipe is knowable and actionable.
Buyers are paying for this intelligence. Datassential's Social Listening tool shows foodservice professionals already spending money to operationalize social trends. Grocery buyers want early warning. CPG brands want to ride demand spikes. The budget exists.
Creator monetization is fragmented. Food creators currently earn through affiliate links, brand deals, or nothing. There's no canonical tool that says: "Here's your official cart, here's your revenue share, here's your analytics."
What You're Selling (3 Synergized Plays)
- To Creators: The Official Cart
Unlock the Vault.
Join founders who spot opportunities ahead of the crowd. Actionable insights. Zero fluff.
“Intelligent, bold, minus the pretense.”
“Like discovering the cheat codes of the startup world.”
“SH is off-Broadway for founders — weird, sharp, and ahead of the curve.”
